By James B. Freeman

ISBN-10: 0511082126

ISBN-13: 9780511082122

ISBN-10: 0521833019

ISBN-13: 9780521833011

Whilst, if ever, is one justified in accepting the premises of a controversy? what's the right criterion of premise acceptability? delivering a accomplished conception of premise acceptability, this publication solutions those questions from an epistemological procedure that the writer calls "common experience foundationalism". His paintings might be of curiosity to experts in casual good judgment, severe pondering and argumentation conception in addition to to a broader variety of philosophers and people educating rhetoric.

Show description

Read Online or Download Acceptable Premises: An Epistemic Approach to an Informal Logic Problem PDF

Similar logic & language books

Get Wittgenstein's Notes on Logic PDF

Wittgenstein's philosophical occupation begun in 1911 while he went to Cambridge to paintings with Russell. He compiled the Notes on good judgment years later as one of those precis of the paintings he had performed to this point. Russell idea that they have been 'as strong as whatever that has ever been performed in logic', yet he had Wittgenstein himself to provide an explanation for them to him.

Get Applying Nature's Design: Corridors as a Strategy for PDF

The fragmenting of habitats is endangering animal populations and degrading or destroying many plant populations in the course of the global. to handle this challenge, conservationists have more and more grew to become to organic corridors, components of land put aside to facilitate the flow of species and ecological approaches.

Philosophy: The Concept and its Manifestations - download pdf or read online

The current ebook is anxious with the character of philosophy and with the scope of philosophical curiosity. It combines an research of the key varieties of philosophical considering as they emerged within the heritage of philosophical principles with an try and study difficulties which recurrent­ ly emerge in philosophical discourse.

Rene Cori, Daniel Lascar, Donald H. Pelletier's Mathematical Logic : A course with exercises -- Part I -- PDF

Good judgment kinds the foundation of arithmetic and is a primary a part of any arithmetic direction. This ebook presents scholars with a transparent and available advent to this crucial topic, utilizing the idea that of version because the major concentration and masking a large sector of good judgment. The chapters of the publication conceal propositional calculus, boolean algebras, predicate calculus and completeness theorems with solutions to all the routines and the tip of the quantity.

Additional resources for Acceptable Premises: An Epistemic Approach to an Informal Logic Problem

Example text

This suggests a distinction between presumptively justified beliefs, and establishing that there is a presumption for such beliefs. If there is a presumption for a belief for a particular person qua challenger, need she be aware of that presumption? Is there a presumption for her belief from her perspective only if she has determined that there is such a presumption by determining or recognizing that a suitably favorable indicator is present in these circumstances and no already-justified counterindicators are likewise present?

Our task in Part II of this book is to present a systematic account both of these presumption determining questions and these principles. However, there are some significant philosophical issues we must deal with first. We turn to those issues in the next two chapters. We want to conclude this chapter by comparing our criterion of acceptability in terms of presumption with two other recent accounts of acceptability, Blair and Johnson’s analysis in terms of model interlocutors in (1987) and Wellman’s account in (1971).

That should make it likely that X’s are Y’s. 7 Our assessment of whether a claim is true, dubious, or false seems to proceed without the determination of probability values. Indeed, one could ask what Grennan’s probability ascriptions actually mean. Because we are examining the claim that a statement is acceptable just in case it is probable, the sense of probability here is monadic rather than binary. We are not talking about a statement’s being probable relative to a set of premises. Rather, we are talking about a statement’s being probable simpliciter.

Download PDF sample

Acceptable Premises: An Epistemic Approach to an Informal Logic Problem by James B. Freeman

by David

Rated 4.12 of 5 – based on 48 votes